St. Paul?s Evangelical Lutheran Church of Coney Island, the oldest Christian fellowship in the Coney Island Brighton area. It began in 1875 as a Congregational Sunday School meeting in the Brighton Chapel until the turn of the century. In 1907 the congregation re-incorporated as St. Paul?s Evangelical Lutheran Church of Coney Island, and met in a newly constructed house of worship on west 5th street near Lincoln High School.