Since 1948, Families and Businesses have turned to McClain Matthews for their Insurance Needs. We are your one-stop agency for Auto insurance, Home insurance, Business insurance and more in Indianapolis. McClain Matthews Insurance opened its family owned business in 1948 with an unwavering commitment to provide the security and peace of mind individuals, families and businesses need to properly protect against risk. Our full-service independent agency is an integral part of the communities we serve and, because we live and work here, we understand what you need to safeguard your loved ones, employees, customers, property and assets.