Pizza Pit - Milton / Edgerton / Newville Owner verified

About

Pizza Pit Milton / Edgerton / Newville is known for the best pizza in Milton, WI and Edgerton, WI, offering fast pizza delivery, carryout, and dine-in. Conveniently located in Milton, we serve fresh, made-from-scratch pizza with hand-tossed dough, house-made sauce, and premium toppings. Choose from thin crust, traditional, thick, or gluten-free pizza, or build your own exactly how you like it.
Voted a local favorite and recognized for best pizza, chicken wings, sandwiches, and catering, Pizza Pit is also known for award-winning chicken wings, Athens gyros, hot sandwiches, and appetizers—perfect for lunch, dinner, game day, or late-night food.
Searching for pizza near me, pizza delivery in Milton WI, Edgerton WI, or Newville WI, or the best wings near you? Pizza Pit delivers fast, fresh, and hot to Milton, Edgerton, Newville, and surrounding areas. Order online today for a trusted hometown favorite serving quality food since 1969

Extra info

Images

Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza

Pepperoni and Ham Pizza

Pizza Slice

Deluxe Combo Pizza

Meat Sampler Combo Pizza

Athens Gyro Cone

Italian Sausage and Mushroom pizza

Italian Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza

Oven Toasted Subs

Macaroni and cheese pizza with sides

Chicken Tenders

Winner Best Pizza, Best Chicken Wings, Best Lunch, and Best Sandwiches 2025.

Athens Gyro Plate

Pit Stix

Breadsticks

Breaded chicken wings with dipper sauce

Pepperoni pizza and chicken wings with dipper sauces

Super Meat Sampler Combo

Cheese curds

Classic cheese pizza

jalapeno poppers

Mac and cheese pizza

Mac and cheese pizza

Super meat sampler combo

Mozzarella Sticks

Mozzarella Sticks

Mozzarella Sticks

Onion Rings

Onion Rings

Classic Pizza

Videos

Best Pizza and Best Chicken Wings 2023 by Madison.com and Wisconsin State Journal Pizza Pit

Pizza Twins 15 seconds. 2 Classic Pizzas of the same size for one low price.

Pizza Pit commercial Fall 2025 Pizza and Chicken Wing deal. 15 seconds

Pizza Pit commercial Fall 2025 Pizza and Chicken Wing deal. 10 seconds

Pizza Pit commercial Fall 2025 Pizza and Chicken Wing deal. 30 seconds

30 second pizza pit commercial fall 2025 pizza and boneless chicken wings

15 second pizza pit commercial fall 2025 pizza and boneless wings

Pizza Pit and Athens Gyros commercial for March 2026. Pizza, Chicken Wings, Athens Gyros and more

Frequently Asked Questions