Jim and Lynn McCaffrey's primary objective is to establish a relationship - a partnership - between you, the insurance company and our offices, to provide you with Coverage, Loss Control Services and above all Claim Services that are second to none. McCaffrey Insurance Agency serves the Home, Auto, and Business Insurance needs of Individuals, Families, and Businesses in Columbus, Dublin, Upper Arlington, Grandview, Worthington, Shawnee Hills, Pickerington, Whitehall, Lancaster, Circleville, Delaware, Granville, London, Marysville, Newark, Pataskala, Sunbury, Westerville, and throughout Ohio